Greece is usually planned as an island choice, which quietly discards the mainland, where most of the archaeology is and where prices are a fraction of those on the famous islands. The best trips generally use both, and the first decision is which island group rather than which island.
Is Athens worth staying in?
Two nights, yes, and more if ruins interest you. The Acropolis and the Acropolis Museum together are a full day and among the most rewarding in Europe. The Ancient Agora, the Temple of Olympian Zeus and the National Archaeological Museum fill a second. The city has also improved enormously as a place to eat and drink, and the neighbourhoods below the Acropolis are pleasant in the evening.
Which island group should you choose?
The Cyclades for the postcard image of white villages and blue domes, which means Santorini, Mykonos, Paros and Naxos. They are the busiest and the windiest, since the meltemi blows hard through August.
The Ionian islands on the west side, meaning Corfu, Kefalonia and Zakynthos, are greener, sandier, calmer in high summer and much better with children. The Dodecanese, including Rhodes and Kos, combine good beaches with genuine historic towns. Crete is large enough to be a destination in its own right and works for a full fortnight.
What are the essential sites?
The Acropolis first. Then Delphi, the most beautifully sited ruin in the country and an easy day from Athens. Ancient Olympia, Mycenae and the theatre at Epidaurus in the Peloponnese. On Crete, the Minoan palace at Knossos. The medieval old town of Rhodes is a walled city still lived in, and the best preserved of its kind in the Mediterranean.
What does the mainland offer beyond ruins?
The Peloponnese is the strongest underused region, with beaches, mountain villages and Venetian towns such as Nafplio and Monemvasia. The Meteora monasteries, perched on rock pillars in central Greece, are among the most extraordinary sights in Europe and reachable by train from Athens. Thessaloniki in the north is the second city and considerably livelier than its profile suggests.
Is Greece expensive?
It depends almost entirely on the island rather than the country. Santorini and Mykonos in August are among the most expensive places in the Mediterranean, while a mid-sized island in the Dodecanese in the same week costs a third as much for a better room. Ferries are broadly fixed in price, so nearly all the variation sits in accommodation and restaurants.
How long do you need?
A week for one island plus Athens. Ten days to combine Athens, one mainland region and one island. Island hopping needs at least two nights per island to be worth the ferry, and you should stay within a single group rather than crossing between them.
When is the best time to visit?
September is the best month overall, with the sea at its annual warmest and the crowds thinning. Early October is the best value. April and May are ideal for Athens and the archaeological sites but the sea is cold. July and August are hot, expensive and windy in the Cyclades.
What do people get wrong?
Booking a ferry on the day of the flight home, which is how people miss flights when wind cancels sailings. The other is assuming small islands stay open: many wind down entirely from mid-October, and a beautiful island with one taverna trading is a different holiday.
Do you need a car in Greece?
Not in Athens, where the metro is good and traffic is punishing. On the islands it depends on size: Crete, Rhodes and Naxos effectively need one, because the bus network serves residents rather than beaches and runs to a timetable built around school and market days. On a small island, a scooter or the single bus route is enough. In the Peloponnese a car is essential, since the archaeological sites are scattered across a large area with almost no public transport between them.
Where to Visit in Portugal: Cities, Coast and Douro goes into more detail on a closely related question, and the rest of our Destinations section covers the wider subject.
The short answer
Two nights in Athens for the Acropolis, then the Ionian islands if you want sand and calm, the Cyclades for the classic look, or Crete if you want one place for a fortnight. Add Delphi or Meteora, and never sail on the day you fly.