Spain is the second most visited country on earth and it is not one destination. The green Atlantic north, the Moorish south, the Catalan northeast and the volcanic Canaries have different climates, different food and in some cases different languages. Choosing Spain settles almost nothing, so the useful question is which Spain you want.
Where should you go first?
Andalusia, if this is a first visit and you want the Spain of the imagination. Seville, Granada and Cordoba sit within two hours of each other by fast train, and between them hold the Alhambra, the Mezquita and the largest Gothic cathedral in the world. A week covering the three is the strongest introduction the country offers.
Barcelona and Madrid are the alternative openings and they are very different cities. Barcelona is compact, coastal and architectural, with the Sagrada Familia and Park Guell as the anchors. Madrid is grander, has no beach, and holds the better art, with the Prado and the Reina Sofia a short walk apart.
What are the essential attractions?
The Alhambra in Granada is the one thing in Spain worth building a trip around, and it needs booking weeks ahead. After that: the Sagrada Familia, the Prado, the Mezquita of Cordoba, the Roman aqueduct at Segovia, the Guggenheim in Bilbao and the walled city of Toledo. The Camino de Santiago is a different kind of attraction and rewards even a few days of walking.
Which coast should you choose?
The Costa Brava north of Barcelona for coves and pine. The Costa Blanca around Alicante for warm shallow water and family resorts. The Costa de la Luz near Cadiz for enormous Atlantic beaches and far fewer visitors. The Costa del Sol is the busiest and the best served by flights. The Balearics offer all of it in miniature, with Menorca the quietest and Mallorca far more varied than its reputation suggests.
Where do most visitors never go?
The northern coast, which is the most rewarding underused part of Spain. San Sebastian has arguably the best food in Europe, Bilbao has the Guggenheim, and Asturias and Galicia are green, mountainous and almost empty of foreign visitors. The catch is the weather, which is Atlantic rather than Mediterranean, so this is a summer region rather than a year-round one.
Do you need a car?
Not for a city trip, since the fast rail network links Madrid, Seville, Cordoba, Malaga and Barcelona efficiently and cheaply when booked ahead. A car earns its place in rural Andalusia, the northern coast and Mallorca, where the villages and coves worth finding sit between the towns rather than in them.
How long do you need?
Four nights for one city, a week for a region, and ten days if you want to combine a city with a coast. Spain is large and the high-speed rail is excellent between major cities but thin elsewhere, so a plan hopping between Barcelona, Seville and Bilbao will spend a great deal of itself in transit.
When is the best time to visit?
April to June and September to October for the cities and the interior. Inland Andalusia in July and August regularly passes forty degrees and sightseeing becomes genuinely unpleasant. The Mediterranean coast is swimmable from late May to mid-October, and the Canaries work every month of the year, which makes them the only reliable winter option.
What do people get wrong?
Eating too early and moving too often. Spanish dinner service rarely starts before half past eight, and arriving at seven puts you in an empty tourist restaurant. The second mistake is treating Spain as small: Seville to Barcelona is further than London to Edinburgh, and a week with four bases is a week of stations.
Anyone weighing this up will also want What to See in Italy: The Places Worth Your Time, along with the rest of the Destinations section.
The short answer
Andalusia for a first trip, Barcelona or Madrid for a city break, the Costa Blanca for a family beach week, and the north for food and green landscape. Pick one region per week and let the rest wait for another visit.