Whether all inclusive saves money has one main determinant: how expensive it is to eat and drink outside the hotel. In countries where that is cheap, all inclusive is usually poor value. Where it is expensive or impractical, it is usually excellent value. The arithmetic follows from that and not from the headline price.
How do you work out the break-even?
Take the difference between the half board and all inclusive price for the same room and divide by the number of days. That gives you a daily figure. Then estimate what you would actually spend on lunch, dinner drinks, poolside drinks and snacks locally. If your estimate exceeds the daily figure, all inclusive wins.
Be honest about the drinking. Most all inclusive pricing assumes a level of consumption that light drinkers never reach, which is where the margin sits.
Where does it win?
Turkey, Bulgaria and Egypt, where the standard is high, the price gap is small and many resorts are some distance from a town. Also anywhere the hotel is isolated, where the alternative is a taxi to dinner every night.
It wins for families with children old enough to eat and drink steadily through the day, where the soft drinks and ice creams alone make a difference.
Where does it lose?
Spain, Portugal, Italy and Greece, where a good meal out is inexpensive, the resorts sit in or beside real towns, and eating locally is a large part of why people go. Paying in advance for food you then decline is a poor trade.
It also loses for light eaters, light drinkers, couples who want to eat out, and anyone planning day trips, since a day away from the hotel means paying twice.
What about the drinks specifically?
This is where all inclusive pricing is built. Two or three drinks a day each is usually enough to justify the upgrade in most Mediterranean resorts. One drink with dinner is not. Anyone who does not drink alcohol is generally better on half board with a good breakfast.
Is half board a better compromise?
Very often, and it is underused. Breakfast and dinner included leaves you free for a cheap lunch out, which is when southern European restaurants are at their best value. For a couple in Spain, Portugal, Italy or Greece, half board plus set lunches usually beats all inclusive on both cost and enjoyment.
Does the length of stay matter?
Yes. On a fortnight, the difference compounds and the case for all inclusive strengthens if you were going to eat in the hotel anyway. On a short break of three or four nights it rarely pays, since you are unlikely to consume enough and you probably want to explore.
What about the hidden costs?
All inclusive resorts commonly charge for a la carte restaurants beyond an allowance, premium spirits, motorised watersports, spa treatments and sometimes beach sunbeds. A resort that appears fully covered can still generate a meaningful bill at checkout, which undermines the budgeting benefit people buy it for.
Does it change how you behave?
Most people find it does, and not always in the direction they expected. Having paid in advance produces a pull towards eating and drinking inside the hotel even when something better is available outside, which is the mechanism by which all inclusive quietly becomes poor value for people who intended to explore. Knowing that in advance is most of the defence against it.
What about children?
The case is stronger than for adults, because children graze constantly and the soft drinks, ice creams and snacks that would otherwise be bought individually add up quickly. It also removes the running negotiation over whether they can have something, which many parents value independently of the arithmetic.
Anyone weighing this up will also want Which Countries Do All Inclusive Best?, along with the rest of the Holidays section.
The short answer
Divide the upgrade cost by the number of days and compare it honestly with what you would spend locally. All inclusive wins in Turkey, Bulgaria and at isolated resorts, and loses in Spain, Greece, Italy and Portugal where eating out is cheap. Half board is frequently the better answer for couples.