Most trips involve people who want different things, and the common approach of finding something everyone half wants produces days that nobody enjoys. The better structure is to divide rather than average.
What is the core principle?
Each person gets days rather than a diluted version of every day. One museum morning for one person, one beach afternoon for another, and everyone accepts the days that are not theirs. This works considerably better than constant negotiation.
Is splitting up acceptable?
Entirely, and underused. Spending a morning apart and meeting for lunch means two people each do what they wanted, and they have something to talk about. Groups that never separate are usually the ones that get tired of each other.
How does base choice help?
More than the itinerary does. A base with a beach, a town and something to see within reach lets people choose each morning without anyone travelling. Choosing a versatile base removes most of the planning conflict at the start.
Which destinations suit mixed groups?
Places with several things within a short radius. Naples, with a city, a coast, ruins and islands. Barcelona and the Costa Brava. Split and the islands. Athens and the Saronic. Sicily, which has everything within a couple of hours.
What about different energy levels?
A real issue and frequently unspoken. Older travellers, young children and anyone with mobility limits need shorter days, and a plan built around the most energetic person exhausts everyone else. Building in an afternoon break serves everybody.
How do you handle different budgets?
By raising it before booking rather than at a restaurant. Agreeing a rough nightly spend for accommodation and keeping expensive activities optional prevents the quiet resentment that otherwise develops.
What about multigenerational trips?
The version where this matters most. A rental or a villa with a pool suits three generations better than a hotel, since there is somewhere to be together and somewhere to be apart. Ground floor rooms and step-free access are worth checking.
How much should be fixed?
One thing a day at most, agreed in advance, with the rest left open. A group itinerary with four fixed points a day gives nobody any say and generates friction at every transition.
What is worth doing together?
Eating, mostly. A group that separates during the day and reconvenes for dinner functions better than one that stays together for twelve hours. One shared meal a day is enough structure for most groups.
What should you discuss before booking?
The pace, the budget, whether splitting up is acceptable and what each person most wants from the trip. Ten minutes of that conversation before paying a deposit prevents most of the difficulty that follows.
What about travelling with teenagers?
The clearest case for dividing days. Teenagers want independence and a phone signal rather than guided anything, and giving them an afternoon alone in a safe central area frequently improves the whole trip for everyone.
How do you choose the accommodation?
Somewhere with communal space, since a group confined to bedrooms has nowhere to be together or apart. A rental with a terrace and a kitchen, or a hotel with a decent bar and lounge, does more for a mixed group than location alone.
Who should do the planning?
One person co-ordinating with input rather than a committee, since group planning by consensus produces either paralysis or the blandest option. Everyone naming one thing they want, and the planner fitting them in, works better than deciding everything together. It also means nobody can claim afterwards that their day never happened, which is the quiet source of most group friction. Writing the agreed days down somewhere everyone can see them costs nothing and settles it.
It is worth reading alongside What Should a First Interrail Trip Look Like?, which takes a different angle, and the wider Inspiration guides.
The short answer
Divide the days rather than averaging the compromises, and treat splitting up as normal. Choose a versatile base with several options within reach, fix one thing a day at most, and agree pace and budget before booking rather than during the trip.