The comparison that matters is door to door rather than the flight time against the train time. A ninety-minute flight is four hours by the time airports, security, waiting and two transfers are included, which changes the answer for most European city pairs.
Where is the crossover?
Around four hours of rail journey. Below that the train almost always wins on total time; above it flying starts to pay, and above six hours it usually does decisively unless the train is overnight.
What does a flight actually cost in time?
Roughly three hours beyond the flight itself: getting to the airport, arriving ahead of departure, waiting, disembarking, baggage and the transfer into the city. Airports are frequently far from the centre and the transfer is rarely quick.
Which routes are clearly rail?
Rome to Florence or Naples, Paris to Brussels or London, Madrid to Barcelona or Seville, Vienna to Budapest or Salzburg, Berlin to Hamburg or Leipzig, and Lisbon to Porto. All are under three hours centre to centre.
Which are clearly flights?
Anything crossing the continent: Lisbon to Vienna, Athens to Paris, Madrid to Berlin. Also island routes and anywhere the rail network is thin, which includes much of the Balkans and parts of eastern Europe.
What about cost?
Budget flights frequently look cheaper and frequently are not once baggage, seat selection and two airport transfers are added. Advance rail fares in Spain, France, Italy and Germany are competitive when booked early and expensive when booked late.
What about comfort?
Not close. Trains have space, no baggage limits worth worrying about, working wifi on many routes, a window and the ability to walk about. The journey is usable time rather than dead time, which is worth something on a short trip.
What about sleeper trains?
A third option that has expanded considerably, particularly through the Austrian night network. A sleeper saves a night of accommodation and delivers you to a city centre in the morning, which for eight to twelve hour journeys is efficient.
Do you need to book rail ahead?
For high-speed services, yes, both for price and because reservations are compulsory on many of them. Regional trains can be taken on the day at a fixed fare, which is one of their advantages.
What about carbon?
Rail produces substantially lower emissions per passenger than flying the same route, which for anyone weighing it is a clear difference rather than a marginal one.
What about delays?
EU rules give passengers rights to assistance and compensation on both rail and air, with different thresholds. Rail delays are generally shorter and easier to absorb, and a missed connection is usually resolved on the next service.
What about luggage?
A significant practical difference. Rail has no meaningful weight limit and no baggage fees, while budget airlines charge substantially for anything beyond a small bag. For a family this alone can reverse the cost comparison.
Does it change with children?
Strongly in favour of rail. Children can move about, there is no security queue to manage, and prams and equipment travel free. A four-hour train with a toddler is considerably easier than a two-hour flight with the same child.
Which cities have difficult airports?
Those where the airport is a long way out or poorly connected, which adds considerably to the real journey. Checking the transfer time and cost before comparing with rail is what makes the comparison honest rather than theoretical.
What about getting to the station?
Usually the simplest part, since European main stations sit in city centres and are reachable on foot or by one metro ride. That proximity is the largest single advantage rail holds over flying on short routes.
See also Which Rail Routes Make a Good Trip?, which covers a related part of the same decision, and our other Inspiration guides.
The short answer
Take the train under four hours and fly over six, comparing door to door rather than flight time. Rome to Florence, Madrid to Barcelona and Vienna to Budapest are all clearly rail. Book high-speed services early, and consider a sleeper for eight to twelve hour journeys.