Warmth and openness are separate questions, and the second catches out more winter travellers than the first. A resort can be eighteen degrees and sunny with two restaurants trading, a closed pool and a bus running three times a day, which is not the holiday the photographs suggested.
Which destinations stay fully open?
The Canary Islands, where winter is peak season rather than the off season. Everything operates, hotels are full, restaurants compete and flight schedules are at their strongest. This is the fundamental practical advantage the Canaries hold over every Mediterranean alternative.
What about Madeira?
Also open year round, particularly Funchal, which is a working city. Some mountain restaurants and smaller properties reduce hours. The New Year period is the busiest of the year.
Which Mediterranean places stay functional?
Those attached to real towns rather than purpose-built resorts. Paphos and Limassol in Cyprus. Valletta and Sliema in Malta. Faro, Lagos and Tavira in the Algarve. Malaga, Cadiz and Almeria in Spain. All have year-round populations and continue to function normally.
Which close?
Purpose-built resort strips with no resident population. Ayia Napa and Protaras in Cyprus are very quiet in winter. Albufeira and Vilamoura in the Algarve reduce sharply. Most Greek islands, most of the Croatian coast and the Turkish resorts close almost entirely.
Why does it happen?
Because a business serving only visitors cannot cover its costs through a winter with no visitors, so it shuts and reopens in spring. Businesses with local customers stay open. That distinction is the whole rule and it predicts almost every case.
How do you check?
Email the accommodation and ask directly which restaurants, bars and pools will be operating in your specific week, which is the only reliable method. Reviews from the same month in previous years are the second source. Satellite and street imagery will not tell you, and the hotel website describes August.
What should you ask specifically?
Whether the pool is heated and open. How many on-site restaurants will run. Whether the beach has sunbed hire. Whether the local bus is on a winter timetable. And when the hotel itself closes, since some accept bookings up to a date while the resort around them has already shut.
Is a quiet resort a bad thing?
Not necessarily, and many people prefer it. An empty Algarve town in January with three good restaurants open is genuinely pleasant and very cheap. The problem is only ever that it was a surprise rather than a choice.
Which is the safest choice?
The southern Canaries for a full resort experience, or a working town anywhere in the southern Mediterranean for a quieter one with everything functioning. The combination to avoid is a purpose-built resort in a Mediterranean destination out of season.
What about flight schedules?
The other half of the same question. Routes to Greek islands, Croatia, Turkey and smaller Mediterranean airports stop entirely from late October and restart in spring, so a destination can be open and unreachable. Canary routes run year round with the strongest winter schedules in Europe.
Do ferries keep running?
Canarian inter-island ferries run year round on a full schedule. Mediterranean island services reduce sharply and some routes stop, which matters if your plan involves reaching an island in January.
What about attractions?
Many reduce their opening hours rather than closing, and some sites in Greece, Italy and Turkey shut earlier in the afternoon during winter, which combined with short days limits what fits into a day.
What about staff and service?
Resorts run reduced staffing out of season, which affects how quickly things are fixed and how many facilities are supervised. It is rarely a problem and it explains why a hotel that felt slick in August can feel thin in February.
Are prices lower because of it?
Yes, and that is the honest trade. A Mediterranean resort in winter is cheap precisely because it is running at a fraction of capacity.
See also Where Is Best for Winter Sun at Christmas?, which covers a related part of the same decision, and our other Seasons guides.
The short answer
The Canaries stay fully open because winter is their high season. In the Mediterranean, choose a town with a resident population rather than a resort strip, and email the accommodation to ask exactly what will be operating in your week.