October is the most misjudged month in Europe. Half the continent is still comfortably warm with the sea at its most pleasant, and the other half has turned. The dividing line also moves considerably between the first week and the last, so the specific dates matter more in October than in any other month.
Where is it reliably warm?
The Canary Islands, without qualification. Air temperatures sit in the mid-twenties, the sea is around twenty-three degrees, and October is one of the sunnier months there. This is the only part of Europe where a late October beach holiday is a safe rather than a hopeful booking.
Cyprus and Malta come next and are excellent for the first three weeks. Cyprus in particular holds sea temperatures around twenty-five degrees, warmer than the Greek islands, and October is one of its best months. Both cool noticeably in the final week.
Southern Turkey, Rhodes, Crete and the Costa del Sol form the next tier, all comfortable to around the twentieth of the month, with warm seas and a real chance of a wet day.
Where does October catch people out?
The Cyclades and smaller Greek islands, where the weather is fine but the infrastructure is closing. Ferries reduce, hotels shut and restaurants that were open in September are boarded up by the middle of the month. The same applies to smaller Croatian and Italian islands.
Portugal is a second trap. The Algarve air stays pleasant but the Atlantic drops quickly, and October swimming there is a much colder proposition than the temperature chart implies.
Which is warmer, the sea or the air?
The sea, and this is October in a sentence. Mediterranean water lags the air by about two months, so it is still holding late summer heat while the mornings and evenings have cooled. Swimming is often more comfortable in October than in June, even where the air temperature is identical.
What about the cities?
October is arguably the best month of the year for southern European cities. Rome, Seville, Athens, Lisbon and Barcelona are all in the low twenties, warm enough to be outside all day and cool enough to walk for hours, with summer crowds gone and prices down. If sightseeing rather than swimming is the point, October is the month to book.
Northern cities are a different matter. Amsterdam, Copenhagen, Berlin and Prague are cool, often wet and increasingly dark, though this suits a museum and restaurant trip perfectly well.
Does the half of the month matter?
More than in any other month. The first fortnight in the Mediterranean is essentially an extension of September. The second fortnight is the beginning of winter almost everywhere except the Canaries, Cyprus and Malta. Clocks change in late October, and losing an hour of evening light changes how a place feels more than a couple of degrees does.
Where should you go for what?
The Canaries for a guaranteed beach week at any point in the month. Cyprus or Malta for warm sea in the first three weeks. Southern Spain, Crete or Rhodes for a good-value beach week before the twentieth. Any southern European city for the best sightseeing weather of the year.
What are the risks of booking October?
Two, and both are manageable. The first is rain, which becomes a genuine possibility across the Mediterranean rather than the remote chance it is in July, and can arrive as a heavy short storm rather than a grey day. The second is closure, since hotels, restaurants and excursions wind down on their own schedules and a resort can feel half shut in the final week. Check when your accommodation closes for the season, and check whether the pool is heated, because an unheated pool in late October is decorative rather than usable.
Is Croatia or Greece Better for Island Hopping? answers a related question in more depth, and there is more of the same across our Destinations guides.
The short answer
The Canary Islands for certainty, Cyprus and Malta for warm sea early in the month, and southern European cities for the best walking weather of the year. Check closing dates before booking a small island, because good weather is no help if the ferry has stopped.