Drinks are where all inclusive economics are decided and where the quality gap between resorts is widest. A good resort pours recognisable beer, drinkable wine and reasonable spirits; a poor one serves something approximate and dispenses it from a machine. The difference is largely predictable.
What does local brand mean?
It means spirits produced in the destination country rather than the international brands you know. In Turkey, Spain and Greece these are often perfectly good. In some markets they are considerably rougher, particularly in the cheapest properties. Local beer is almost always fine and frequently better than the imported alternative.
What about the wine?
The weakest element at almost every all inclusive resort, usually served from a dispenser or a box and rarely representative of what the country produces. In wine-producing countries this is particularly frustrating, since a modest bottle from a local shop would be far better. Many resorts sell bottled wine at a supplement, which is often worth paying.
Are cocktails included?
Usually a defined list made with local spirits, with anything requiring a branded spirit charged. Quality varies enormously and the pre-mixed approach is common. At the upper end and in Turkish ultra resorts, cocktails are made properly to order.
What are the serving hours?
The thing that matters most and the thing least often checked. Typical patterns run from ten in the morning to eleven at night, with bars closing in sequence. Some resorts serve until late or continuously; others stop at ten. Some only serve alcohol with meals. Ask directly, because this shapes the evenings more than the brands do.
What about measures?
Frequently smaller than at home, and often poured through optics or from a dispensing gun. Some resorts limit the number of drinks served at once, which is a reasonable crowd-management measure rather than meanness. Glasses are usually plastic near pools for safety reasons.
How do you tell before booking?
The hotel concept sheet lists the brands covered at each board level. Recent reviews mentioning the bar are the other source, and the words to search for are watered, dispenser and closed. Photographs posted by guests of the bar back shelf tell you a great deal in one glance.
Which countries pour best?
Turkey at ultra level, where branded spirits and proper cocktails are standard. Spain and the Canaries are reliable at the mid and upper end. Greece is variable. Bulgaria has the widest range between the cheapest and the best properties of anywhere in Europe.
Is it worth bringing your own?
Most resorts prohibit bringing alcohol into public areas and many have a policy on what may be brought to the room. Duty free bought at the airport is generally fine in the room and not by the pool. Attempting to fill a resort cup from your own bottle is both against the rules and obvious.
What about soft drinks and coffee?
Included almost everywhere and usually dispensed from a machine, which means post-mix rather than bottled and coffee from a push-button machine rather than made. Proper espresso from the lobby bar is frequently charged, which is a small but consistent annoyance in Italy, Spain and Greece where the coffee culture makes the contrast obvious.
Does it vary through the day?
Often. Many resorts run a smaller selection at the pool bar than at the main bar, and a reduced list late at night once the main bar closes. The beach bar, where there is one, is frequently the most limited of all. If the pool bar matters to you, ask what it serves rather than what the resort serves. Swim-up bars are the exception and usually carry the full range, which is part of why rooms near them command a premium.
If you are planning further, Do You Still See the Country on an All Inclusive? covers the next part of the decision, and there is more in our Holidays guides.
The short answer
Local beer is usually good, local spirits are variable, and the wine is almost always the weakest element. Check the serving hours and the brand list on the concept sheet before booking, and consider paying the supplement for bottled wine rather than the ultra upgrade.