The assumption that booking independently is always cheaper is out of date for a large part of the European market. Tour operators buy seats and beds in bulk at rates individuals cannot access, and on mainstream beach routes in summer a package frequently undercuts the same components bought separately.
When does a package win?
On established beach routes in peak season. A week in the Balearics, the Canaries, the Algarve, mainland Spain, Greece or Turkey in July and August is where operators have the most inventory and the deepest discounts. All inclusive in particular is very difficult to beat independently, because the rate the operator pays the hotel is not available to the public.
Packages also win for families, since child places and free child offers are a package construct with no direct equivalent when booking separately.
When does booking separately win?
For city breaks, for anything outside a standard week, and for destinations operators do not cover. A three-night trip, a fly-drive, a multi-centre itinerary, an apartment in a town with no package presence, or shoulder-season travel are all usually cheaper and better arranged yourself.
It also wins whenever you want a specific hotel that is not in an operator programme, which is most independent and boutique accommodation.
What does ATOL protection cover?
ATOL is a UK financial protection scheme covering flight-inclusive packages. If the company fails before you travel you get a refund, and if it fails while you are away you are brought home at no cost. It applies to the package as a whole, which is the important distinction: booking a flight and a hotel separately leaves you with neither protection nor anyone responsible for the trip as a unit.
Package Travel Regulations also give you rights if a significant element changes, which is broader than what airlines and hotels individually owe you.
What about a dynamic package?
Many online agents let you combine a flight and hotel of your choosing into a single booking, which is often ATOL protected and priced competitively. This is frequently the best of both, giving you the choice of independent booking with the protection and sometimes the pricing of a package. Check for the ATOL certificate rather than assuming.
How should you compare properly?
Price the package, then price the identical flights, the identical hotel with the same board basis, the transfer and the luggage separately, and compare the totals. Transfers and baggage are where independent bookings quietly lose, since a package usually includes both.
Does it affect what you can complain about?
Yes, and meaningfully. With a package, one company is responsible for the whole holiday, which makes a complaint about a hotel or a transfer straightforward to pursue. Booked separately, a problem with the hotel is between you and the hotel, and a delayed flight does not entitle you to anything from the accommodation you have paid for and missed.
Which should you choose?
Package for a standard beach week in season, all inclusive, or family travel. Independent for cities, short breaks, shoulder season, unusual destinations and specific hotels. Dynamic package when you want a particular combination with protection attached.
What about credit card protection?
Paying by credit card for anything over a hundred pounds gives additional protection under consumer credit rules if the supplier fails or does not deliver, which applies whether you booked a package or separately. Using a credit card for the deposit at least, even if the balance goes on a debit card, is a sensible habit.
Does the operator matter?
For price, yes, and the same hotel and flight combination often appears with several operators at different prices. Check two or three before booking, and check the hotel direct rate as well.
Which European Countries Are Cheapest to Eat Out In? answers a related question in more depth, and there is more of the same across our Holidays guides.
The short answer
Packages usually win on mainstream beach routes in summer and carry ATOL protection; independent booking usually wins for cities, short breaks and anything unusual. Compare like with like including transfers and bags, and check for an ATOL certificate on anything flight-inclusive.