European honeymoons come in three shapes: one place and do nothing, two or three places and see things, or a combination with a city at one end. Deciding which of those you want before choosing a country prevents most of the planning difficulty, because each shape points at different destinations.
Which islands work best?
Santorini for the setting, with the honest caveat that it is crowded and expensive and works best in May or October and for three or four nights rather than a fortnight. Milos, Paros and Naxos give much of the same Cycladic character with a fraction of the crowds.
Capri, Sardinia, Menorca and the Aeolian islands are the Italian and Spanish equivalents, all quieter and several of them cheaper.
Where works for a touring honeymoon?
Italy, principally, where the distances are manageable and the variety is unmatched. Tuscany with a coast, or Rome with Puglia, or the Amalfi Coast with Naples. Portugal works similarly, with Lisbon, the Douro and the Alentejo. Both reward a hire car for part of the trip.
What about the lakes and mountains?
Underused and among the best options for anyone who does not want a beach. Lake Como, Lake Maggiore, Annecy, the Dolomites and the Bernese Oberland all combine spectacular scenery with excellent hotels and food, and they suit late spring and September particularly well.
Should you combine a city with somewhere quiet?
It is the most reliable structure and the one most people settle on. Two or three nights in a city, then a week somewhere still. Venice and the Dolomites, Barcelona and the Costa Brava, Lisbon and the Alentejo, Athens and an island, Naples and the Amalfi Coast all work and require no long transfer between the two halves.
When should you go?
May, June, September and early October across almost all of it. July and August are hot, crowded and at peak prices, and a honeymoon is exactly the trip where paying more for worse conditions makes least sense. If your wedding is in summer, going in September instead is worth considering.
How long should it be?
Ten to fourteen nights suits two locations comfortably. A week suits one place. Three locations in under twelve nights produces travel days that undermine the point.
Should you tell the hotel?
Yes, at the time of booking rather than on arrival. Most properties offer something, and almost all of them apply it only if told in advance. Typical gestures are a room upgrade where available, a bottle of something, or a dinner included. It costs nothing to mention.
What should you avoid?
Long transfers immediately after a wedding, which is when everyone is most tired. Overplanning, which is the commonest regret. Booking the most photographed hotel in the most photographed place in August. And travelling the day after the wedding rather than allowing a day in between.
What about the cost?
Honeymoon pricing exists, and mentioning the occasion sometimes produces an upgrade and sometimes a higher quote. Searching anonymously first and mentioning it after the price is fixed avoids the second. Travelling in September rather than July typically saves more than any negotiation.
Do you need travel insurance for this?
As for any trip, and with attention to the cancellation element given the higher value. Buy it when you book rather than before departure, since that is what covers the period in between, and declare any existing conditions.
Where should you avoid?
Anywhere requiring a long transfer immediately after a wedding, and anywhere at its absolute peak. The most photographed hotels in Santorini, Positano and Capri in August combine the highest prices of the year with the largest crowds, which is the worst combination for a trip built on atmosphere.
If you are planning further, How Do You Plan a Trip When You Want Different Things? covers the next part of the decision, and there is more in our Holidays guides.
The short answer
Decide the shape first: one place, a tour, or a city plus somewhere quiet. The last is the most reliable. Travel in May, June or September, allow ten to fourteen nights for two locations, tell the hotel when you book, and give yourself a day between the wedding and the flight.