Five star rates are several times a good mid-range price, and the question is not whether the hotel is better but whether the difference is used. For some trips it transforms the experience and for others it is a nicer room you sleep in and leave at eight.
What do you actually get?
Space, which is the most reliable difference, with rooms frequently twice the size. A proper bathroom rather than a compact unit. Staff ratios high enough that requests are handled immediately. A concierge who is genuinely useful. And a location that is usually the best in the city.
What do you not necessarily get?
Warmth, character or a memorable stay. Some five star hotels are formal to the point of being uncomfortable, and international luxury chains can feel identical in every city. Paying more removes problems rather than guaranteeing pleasure.
When is it worth it?
On a special occasion, where the hotel is part of the point. On a long stay, where space matters daily. In a destination where the hotel is the destination, such as a spa property or a resort. And when travelling for a short time in a city where the best location saves hours.
When is it not?
On a sightseeing trip where you leave at eight and return at eleven, which describes most city breaks. In cities where the mid-range is excellent and the top end is priced for business travel. And anywhere the money would be better spent on an extra two nights.
Is the service genuinely different?
At a good property, noticeably. The difference is staff numbers, which means problems are solved rather than queued, and knowledge, which means the concierge can actually get you a table. At a poor five star it is formality without substance, which is worse than an honest three star.
What about the breakfast?
Frequently excellent and frequently charged separately even at the top end, which surprises people. It is usually a substantial buffet with cooked items made to order, and it can genuinely replace lunch. Whether it is worth the charge is a separate calculation from the room.
Where does five star mean most?
In countries with strict classification and high service traditions: Switzerland, Austria, Germany and France. In markets where the rating is awarded generously the same stars mean considerably less, which is why the rating alone is a poor guide at this level.
Is there a better use of the money?
Frequently. A well-regarded four star in a better location, a smaller independent with genuine character, or two extra nights at a good mid-range property. The step from three to four star usually buys more per pound than the step from four to five.
How do you get it cheaper?
Travel out of season, when top-end city rates fall sharply. Take a Sunday to Thursday stay in business cities, where weekends are cheaper, or the reverse in leisure destinations. Book direct for member rates and look for packages including breakfast.
What is the honest test?
Whether you will spend time in the hotel. If the answer is a few hours asleep, the money is better spent elsewhere. If the hotel is somewhere you will sit, eat, swim or work, the difference is used and the price makes sense.
Does it differ between cities and resorts?
Substantially. At a resort the hotel is the holiday, so the step up is used all day and the money is well spent. In a city it is a base, and the same step up buys a nicer place to sleep. The resort case for five star is far stronger than the city one.
Are the facilities used?
Rarely, in practice. Most guests paying for a gym, a pool, a spa and three restaurants use one of them once. Paying for facilities you will not use is the commonest way the upper end becomes poor value.
Which Are the Most Famous Hotels in Europe? answers a related question in more depth, and there is more of the same across our Hotels guides.
The short answer
Five stars buys space, service and location reliably, and character unreliably. It is worth it when the hotel is part of the trip and poor value when you only sleep there. A four star in a better street or two extra nights often delivers more.