Advance booking has spread from a few famous attractions to almost everything, and the useful question is which of it genuinely matters. A small number of things sell out weeks ahead; most of the rest can be decided on the day, and leaving room to change your mind is worth protecting.
What genuinely sells out?
Sites with capped numbers: the Alhambra Nasrid Palaces, the Borghese Gallery, Neuschwanstein interior tours, the Last Supper in Milan, Anne Frank House, and several painted caves. These are limited by conservation rather than demand and there is no way in without a slot.
What sells out in high season?
The Sagrada Familia, the Vatican Museums, the Colosseum, the Acropolis, the Uffizi and Sintra in summer. These take far more people and still fill, and booking a timed slot avoids a long queue rather than avoiding exclusion.
What about restaurants?
Worth booking further ahead than in Britain, since good small restaurants across Spain, Italy and France have twenty covers and fill days in advance. Anything with a reputation needs a week or more, and the famous ones need months.
What about transport?
Long-distance trains in France, Spain and Italy are cheapest booked early and sell out on popular routes, and seat reservations are compulsory on many high-speed services. Ferries with vehicles need booking; foot passengers usually do not.
What does not need booking?
Most churches, most viewpoints, most markets, most walks, most parks, smaller museums and almost everything outside the peak weeks. In October or February a great deal of Europe can be walked into.
How far ahead?
Capacity-limited sites, two to three months in summer. Major attractions, one to two weeks. Restaurants, a week. Regional trains, on the day. Nothing benefits from being booked a year ahead except accommodation in high season.
Should you book through the official site?
Almost always, since resellers add a margin and occasionally sell nothing more than a booking service. Search the attraction name and look for the official domain rather than the top sponsored result.
What is the cost of over-booking?
A timetable rather than a holiday. Four timed slots in a day removes the ability to stay somewhere you are enjoying, and a trip built entirely of reservations is frequently more tiring than one with two fixed points a day.
What is the reasonable approach?
Book the capacity-limited things before you travel, one restaurant for any evening that matters, and nothing else. Decide the rest in the morning based on the weather and how you feel.
What if something is sold out?
Check for returns each morning, since cancellations are released. Some sites hold a small allocation for same-day sale at the door. And a guided tour frequently has availability when individual tickets do not, which is one of the main reasons to take one.
Does the season change the answer?
Enormously. From November to March most of Europe can be walked into, and the whole question of advance booking largely disappears except for capacity-limited sites. In July and August it applies to almost everything worth seeing.
What about refunds?
Timed tickets are frequently non-refundable and non-transferable, which is the risk of booking far ahead. Checking the terms matters most for anything weather-dependent such as a boat trip or a mountain lift, where cancellation policies vary widely.
What about tours and experiences?
Small group tours, cooking classes and anything with a dozen places do sell out, particularly in summer and on popular days. Large-group bus tours and general walking tours rarely do, and can usually be booked the evening before.
Should you book accommodation early?
This is the one thing that genuinely benefits from months of notice in high season, since supply is fixed and the good properties sell rather than raise prices. Everything else on the list can wait until a few weeks out.
See also Are Guided Tours Worth Taking?, which covers a related part of the same decision, and our other Inspiration guides.
The short answer
Book capacity-limited sites two to three months ahead in summer, major attractions one or two weeks, restaurants a week, and long-distance trains early for price. Leave everything else, use the official site rather than a reseller, and keep at most two fixed points a day.