Island hopping sounds spontaneous and is the opposite: it is a timetable exercise. Ferries between islands run on fixed routes at fixed frequencies, and the itinerary that works is the one the boats allow rather than the one that looks good on a map.
Where should you start?
With the ferry timetable rather than the islands. Check which routes exist, how often they run and how long they take, then build the route around them. Two islands twenty kilometres apart may have no direct connection at all.
Which groups work best?
The Cyclades, with the densest network in Greece and frequent fast ferries between Mykonos, Paros, Naxos and Santorini. The Dodecanese along the Turkish coast. The Ionian islands. The Croatian islands from Split and Dubrovnik.
Which do not?
Islands in different groups, since Greek ferries run within a group and back to Athens rather than across. Moving from the Cyclades to the Dodecanese frequently means returning to Piraeus or flying, which costs two days.
How long on each island?
Three nights minimum, which gives two full days. Two nights is a stop. Four or five islands in a fortnight is the upper limit, and three is more enjoyable.
What is the main risk?
Cancellation. Ferries do not sail in strong wind, and in the Aegean the meltemi can stop services for a day or more in July and August. This is normal rather than exceptional and it must be planned for.
Build a buffer day before any flight home, and never plan to reach the airport on the morning of departure from a distant island.
Should you book ferries ahead?
In high season, yes, particularly for fast catamarans and for any route with limited sailings. Conventional ferries usually have space for foot passengers, and vehicles always need booking.
How do you choose the islands?
By contrast rather than similarity. One larger island with a town, one quiet one, and one with a specific draw makes a better trip than three of the same kind. Islands without an airport are consistently quieter.
What about accommodation?
Book ahead in July and August, since small islands have genuinely limited capacity. Outside the peak, arriving and finding something is still possible on the larger islands and risky on the small ones.
Which season?
May to early July and September, which combine full ferry schedules with warm water and fewer people. Services reduce sharply from late October, and many small islands lose most connections and close for winter.
Is there a simpler alternative?
One island with day trips, which removes every risk and most of the packing. Naxos, Crete, Hvar and Rhodes all have enough within reach to fill a fortnight, with boat excursions to neighbouring islands returning the same evening.
What about the first and last islands?
Choose them for connections rather than appeal. Starting on a well-connected island with an airport and ending on one within easy reach of your departure point removes the two riskiest moves of the trip.
Do you need a car?
On larger islands, frequently, since the good beaches and villages are not near the port. On small ones a scooter or the bus is enough. Taking a car between islands on ferries is expensive and rarely worth it; hiring on each is simpler.
What should you pack?
Less than for a fixed base, since every ferry means carrying everything up a gangway and frequently along a harbour. A single bag you can walk with for twenty minutes is the practical limit, and wheeled cases struggle on island streets.
Which groups suit a first attempt?
The Cyclades or the Croatian islands from Split, both with frequent services, plenty of accommodation and short crossings. The Dodecanese and the smaller Ionian islands are better for a second trip, when the timetables are more familiar.
Anyone weighing this up will also want Should You Fly or Take the Train Between Cities?, along with the rest of the Inspiration section.
The short answer
Build the route from the ferry timetable rather than the map, stay three nights minimum and take no more than four islands in a fortnight. Stay within one group, book ahead in summer, and leave a buffer day before flying since cancellations are normal.