River cruises have become one of the main ways British visitors see Christmas markets, and they solve a real problem: visiting four or five towns without repacking, checking in and finding transport each time. They also cost considerably more than the same itinerary by train.
What are the main routes?
The Danube, typically Nuremberg to Budapest or Passau to Vienna, taking in Regensburg, Passau, Linz, Melk, Vienna and Bratislava. The Rhine, usually Cologne to Basel or Amsterdam southwards, covering Cologne, Koblenz, Rudesheim, Heidelberg and Strasbourg.
The Moselle, the Main and the Douro all run shorter festive itineraries.
What is included?
Usually accommodation, all meals, some drinks, guided walking tours in each town and transfers. Flights are often extra or sold as a package. Read what drinks are covered, since packages vary considerably between operators.
What is the main advantage?
Unpacking once. On a five-market itinerary that is a genuine saving in time and effort, particularly in winter when moving between hotels with luggage in the cold and dark is unappealing. The ship also docks centrally in most towns, so the market is a short walk away.
What is the main drawback?
Time in each place. Ships typically arrive in the morning and leave in the evening, or dock overnight in only one or two towns, which means you see several markets by day and few after dark. Christmas markets are considerably better in the evening, which is the central tension.
Check the itinerary for overnight moorings rather than assuming.
How does the cost compare?
Substantially more than doing the same route independently. The same towns by train, staying in mid-range hotels and eating at the markets, costs a fraction of a cruise fare. What you are paying for is the convenience, the meals and the absence of logistics.
Who does it suit?
Travellers who want everything arranged, anyone with mobility limitations who would find repeated hotel changes difficult, and people travelling alone who prefer the sociability. It also suits anyone nervous about winter travel logistics.
Who should do it independently?
Anyone who wants evenings at the markets, anyone on a budget, and anyone who would rather spend two nights in one town than six hours in each of five. The Danube and Rhine routes are both extremely well served by trains.
What about the water levels?
A genuine risk worth knowing about. Low or high water on the Rhine and Danube can prevent ships passing, and operators then transfer passengers by coach or swap ships. This happens most winters somewhere on the network and is covered in the terms rather than compensated as a fault.
How far ahead should you book?
Early, since festive sailings are a short season with fixed capacity and they sell out. Prices rise as departure approaches rather than falling.
Is there a middle option?
A rail-based trip staying two nights in each of two or three cities, which gives evenings at the markets without daily packing. Vienna, Bratislava and Budapest, or Cologne, Strasbourg and Colmar, both work this way and are straightforward by train.
What size are the ships?
River vessels carry around a hundred to two hundred passengers, which is far smaller than an ocean cruise and changes the atmosphere considerably. Cabins are compact, most have a window or a small balcony, and public spaces are limited to a lounge, a dining room and a sun deck that is of little use in December.
Are the excursions worth it?
The included walking tours are generally a useful orientation of an hour or two. Optional paid excursions vary, and in market towns the market is usually a short walk from the mooring, which makes independent exploring straightforward.
If you are planning further, Which Markets Are Best for a Weekend Break? covers the next part of the decision, and there is more in our Seasons guides.
The short answer
Worth it for convenience, meals and the absence of logistics, and considerably dearer than the same route by train. Check how many nights the ship moors overnight, since markets are best after dark, and consider two nights each in two or three cities instead.