Service at a twelve-room hotel is a different product from service at a two-hundred-room one. It is personal rather than procedural, which means it is more flexible, more knowledgeable and more genuinely helpful, and it is available for fewer hours by fewer people.
What is better about it?
Decisions. The person at the desk can usually act rather than refer, which means a late checkout, a stored bag, a changed room or a favour is agreed rather than escalated. That flexibility is the single largest practical advantage.
What about local knowledge?
Frequently the best thing on offer. Someone who lives in the neighbourhood and eats where you are about to eat gives recommendations that no concierge script produces. Asking where they had dinner last week is a better question than asking for a restaurant recommendation.
What is worse about it?
Coverage. Reception may close in the evening, there is nobody overnight, and if the one person who handles maintenance is off, a broken shower waits. There is also no redundancy, so an unusual request outside their experience may simply not be met.
How should you handle arrival?
Tell them your arrival time in advance, which matters far more here than at a chain. A small hotel with limited reception hours needs to arrange your check-in, and an unannounced late arrival is the commonest practical failure at this kind of property.
How do you get the most from it?
By engaging early and asking specifically. Email before arrival with what matters to you, whether that is a quiet room, a table booked or advice on a day trip. Small hotels frequently act on this and it is the main mechanism by which the stay is improved.
Is it formal?
Rarely, and this suits some travellers and not others. Expect conversation rather than ceremony, first names, and a degree of informality that a grand hotel would not permit. Anyone who prefers to be left entirely alone may find it intrusive.
What about complaints?
Raise them directly and early, since the person who can fix it is usually in the building. Complaints at small hotels are generally resolved quickly and generously, and the same issue raised in a review afterwards achieves nothing for your own stay.
Should you tip?
Modestly and less routinely than at a large hotel, since there are no porters and the person carrying your bag may be the owner. Housekeeping is tipped as normal. Naming staff in a review is worth more to a small property than to a chain.
Does it depend on the country?
In style rather than quality. Italian, Spanish and Greek small hotels tend towards warmth and conversation, Austrian and Swiss towards precision, and French somewhere between. All are hospitality and they read differently.
What is the warning sign?
A small hotel run remotely, with a keypad, no staff presence and a management company handling messages. That is an apartment operation with a hotel sign, and it delivers none of what small hotel service means.
What about privacy?
The other side of personal service and worth knowing about. In a small hotel the staff notice when you come and go, what you ask for and who you are with. Most travellers find this warm and some find it intrusive, and it is a genuine difference from the anonymity of a chain.
Is anything included that chains charge for?
Frequently. Coffee and water through the day, a drink on arrival, luggage storage and late checkout are all commonly given rather than sold at small properties, since the owner decides rather than a revenue system.
How does it compare with a chain?
Better on flexibility, knowledge and warmth; worse on hours, redundancy and predictability. Neither is superior in the abstract, and which you want depends on whether you value being known or being left alone.
Anyone weighing this up will also want Are Converted Buildings Worth Staying In?, along with the rest of the Hotels section.
The short answer
Expect personal, flexible service with genuine local knowledge, and limited hours with no overnight cover. Tell them your arrival time, email before you arrive with what matters, raise problems immediately, and avoid properties run remotely with nobody on site.